John Cosmich and LaKeysha Isaac Obtain Defense Verdict in New Jersey


A New Jersey state court jury cleared Shulton, Inc. of all liability on November 2 in one of the first lawsuits of its kind to go to trial alleging that a consumer goods company failed to adequately disclose the alleged risks of asbestos-related disease from using cosmetic talc products. Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, Inc., who allegedly supplied the talc which Shulton used in its products, was also cleared of liability.

The 9-member jury returned a defense verdict following a multi-week trial that began on September 8. The jury found that Plaintiff Linda Fishbain failed to prove that either of the Defendants manufactured, sold or distributed a talc product that was not reasonably fit, suitable and safe for its intended or foreseeable use. The panel similarly rejected Fishbain’s claims that the defendants were responsible for her mesothelioma because she was not adequately warned of possible health risks allegedly from the use of cosmetic talc use.

Fishbain claimed that she used Shulton’s former line of cosmetic talc products on a daily basis during the 1960’s and 1970’s. Plaintiffs’ counsel argued that the talc allegedly supplied by Whittaker, Clark & Daniels, which was subsequently used in these products, was contaminated with asbestos fibers and caused Mrs. Fishbain to develop mesothelioma in 2013.

Shulton’s attorney, John D. Cosmich, argued that there was no evidence that the products used by Mrs. Fishbain were actually contaminated and therefore were not a substantial contributing cause of her mesothelioma.

In reaching its verdict, the jury found that at the time the Defendants’ products were sold, it was neither  known  nor  knowable  that  the  products  could  allegedly  cause  an  asbestos-related disease.


back to recent news

Recent News

David W. Baria Joins Cosmich Simmons & Brown

David Baria has joined Cosmich Simmons & Brown as Of Counsel.  David has successfully handled a wide array of cases over his 28... read more

Cosmich Simmons & Brown Launches Blu Chip Analytics

Cosmich Simmons & Brown has launched Blu Chip Analytics, a consultancy providing services in the sports and entertainment industries.  Firm attorneys Michael... read more

Georgia Ainsworth Receives LLM

In August, Georgia Ainsworth, an associate in our New Orleans, Louisiana office, completed the University of Toronto Faculty of Law’s... read more